This website is
 sponsored.gif

banner.gif

 Welcome    Main    Forum    FAQ    Useful Links    Sample Letters   Tribunal  

 

COURT DECISIONS

 

More Pages >  A | B | C |  E |  F | G | H | I |  J | K | L | M | N | O | P | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y 

Links to  websites for other sources of court decisions:

Malaysia Court Homepage - http://www.kehakiman.gov.my

Cases from Malaysia, Singapore and Other Jurisdictions - http://www.ipsofactoj.com


 

 

Aw Yong Wai Choo & Ors v. Arief Trading Sdn Bhd & ANOR 21 SEPTEMBER 1991 - HIGH COURT MALAYA IPOH [HIGH COURT CIVIL SUIT NO. 753 OF 1982 CONSOLIDATED WITH 93/82, 687/82, 688/82, 689/82, 692/82, 693/82, 696/82, 710/82, 711/82, 712/82, 752/82, 754/82, 756/82, 757/82, 759/82, 762/82, 763/82, 764/82, 766/82, 768/82, 769/82, 782/82, 783/82, 784/82, 786/82, 787/82, 789/82, 791/82, 793/82, 794/82, 795/82, 10/83, 20/83, 57/83 & 659/83]
Civil Procedure: Cost - Getting-up fee - Consolidation of actions - Whether getting-up fee must be confined only to points raised at hearing of consolidated action - Whether costs of getting-up should be repeated in each individual case in the consolidated action
Civil Procedure:
Action - Consolidation of actions - Common facts and law and relief claimed - Same transaction or series of transactions - Whether a single action including all plaintiffs would have been more appropriate

Beca (M) Sdn Bhd v. Tang Choong Kuan & Anor. 30 SEPTEMBER 1985 - SUPREME COURT, KOTA KINABALU [FC CIVIL APPEAL NO. 280 OF 1984]

CONTRACT: Housing developers - Sale and purchase of flats - Deposit or "booking fee" - Rule 10(2) of Housing (Control and Licensing of Developers) Rules 1980 - Provisional agreement - Licence - Validity - Void - Section 66 of Contracts Act 1950 - Sections 5, 20 of Housing (Control and Licensing of Developers) Enactment 1978.

City Investment Sdn Bhd. V. Koperasi Serbaguna Cuepacs Tanggungan Bhd 17 DECEMBER 1984 - FEDERAL COURT, KUALA LUMPUR [CIVIL APPEAL NO. 30 OF 1984]
This is a claim by respondents/purchasers for specific performance of immovable property and also for damages and other ancillary reliefs for breach of contract.
Chye Fook & Anor v. Teh Teng Seng Realty Sdn Bhd 27 SEPTEMBER 1988 - HIGH COURT IPOH CIVIL SUIT NO 22-38-87
ENG MEE YONG & ORS V. LETCHUMANAN 04 APRIL 1979 - PRIVY COUNCIL [HONG KONG]  [APPEAL NO. 25 OF 1977]

Faber Merlin (M) Sdn Bhd & Ors V. Lye Thai Sang & Anor.
Tan Kim Chua Realty (M) Sdn Bhd V. Lye Thai Sang & Anor.

11 MARCH 1985 - 18 MAY 1985 - FEDERAL COURT [JOHORE BAHRU]  CIVIL APPEALS NOS 79 AND 90 OF 1984

Fernandaz Holding Sdn Bhd & Yang Lain v. Sharani Holdings (M) Sdn Bhd  & Yang Lain 11 DISEMBER 1990 - MAHKAMAH TINGGI MALAYA, KUALA LUMPUR [GUAMAN SIVIL NO. 86-22-298-87]

KONTRAK: Perjanjian jual beli kondominium - Bangunan tidak disiapkan dalam masa 24 bulan - Kegagalan menjalankan kerja - Makna "pemaju" - Perjanjian terbatal - Tidak dapat diteruskan - Sama ada perbezaan antara pembahagian tanah dengan pembahagian bangunan - Akta Pemaju Perumahan 1966, s. 3 - Kaedah-kaedah Pemaju Perumahan (Kawalan dan Pelesenan) 1970 - Peraturan Pemaju Perumahan (Kawalan dan Pelesenan) 1982, Peraturan 12(1).

HOO SEE SEN & ANOR. V. PUBLIC BANK BHD. & ANOR. 17 MARCH 1988 - SUPREME COURT, KUALA LUMPUR [CIVIL APPEAL NO. 335 OF 1987]
Joseph Peh Soon Keat & Peter Peh Hock Beng v. Newacres Sdn Bhd 22 OCTOBER 1993 -  HIGH COURT KUALA LUMPUR GUAMAN SIVIL NO S-2-22-336 TAHUN 1991
LEE WAH BANK LTD. V. CHI LIUNG HOLDINGS SDN. BHD.13 OCTOBER 1983 - HIGH COURT MALAYA, KUALA LUMPUR VOHRAH J [ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO. F 836 OF 1982]
This is an application by way of an originating summons (see enclosure 2) under O. 5 r. 4(2) of the Rules of the High Court 1980 for a declaration of the rights of two parties under the terms of a written contract.
LEE WAH BANK LTD. V. CHI LIUNG HOLDINGS SDN. BHD.16 JUNE 1984 - FEDERAL COURT, KUALA LUMPUR
ABDUL HAMID OMAR CJ (MALAYA), MOHD. AZMI FJ, SYED AGIL BARAKBAH FJ
[CIVIL APPEAL NO. 291 OF 1983]
The main issue in this appeal is whether the appellants are entitled to the exterior wall of a parcel of business premises within Chi Liung Plaza which they purchased from the respondents by agreement dated 17 November 1980 at the price of RM1.5 million. By the said agreement the respondents agreed

Lee Wai Kin V. Yulek Sdn Bhd.  12 FEBRUARY 1986 - HIGH COURT MALAYA, KUALA LUMPUR
[ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO. F 1013 OF 1985]

LAND LAW: Section 8(1) of Strata Titles Act 1985 - Who should apply for strata title - Prescribed fee under section 10 - When can collect payment from registered proprietor- Terms of the agreement - Construction of.

Lee Wah Bank Ltd  v. Chi Liung Holdings Sdn Bhd 09 MAY 1986 - HIGH COURT OF MALAYA
ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO F1871 OF 1985

CONTRACT: Sale and purchase agreement of business premises - Whether sale inclusive of exterior wall - Installation of ATM through exterior wall - Whether consent of vendor necessary - Whether installation within meaning of "alteration" and "improvement" - Proprietorship of exterior wall - Whether with purchaser - Installation of signboards and logo - Whether purchaser entitled to install without consent of vendor - Meaning of "competent authorities".

Lim Seang Mee v. Keepahead Holdings Sdn Bhd 17 FEBRUARY 1992 - HIGH COURT MALAYA, PULAU PINANG [ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO. 24-26-1992]

Land Law: Housing Developers - Deed of Assignment - Whether it is the Developer's obligation to endorse or just discretion to grant its consent - Administrative fee to grant consent

LIMMEWAH DEVELOPMENT SDN BHD V. DR JASBIR SINGH S/O HARBHAJAN SINGH 17 FEBRUARY 1993 - HIGH COURT [MUAR] CIVIL APPEAL NO 11-1 OF 1990
LOH WAI LIAN V. S.E.A. HOUSING CORP. SDN. BHD.29 SEPTEMBER 1983 - HIGH COURT MALAYA, KUALA LUMPUR MOHAMED DZAIDDIN J [CIVIL SUIT NO. F 210 OF 1982]
CONTRACT: Sales and purchase agreement to purchase house - Late delivery of vacant possession - Liquidated damages.
LIMITATION: Accrual of cause of action - Limitation period for actions arising out of contract - Definition of `cause of action
Loh Wai Lian  v. SEA Housing Corporation Sdn Bhd 28 JUNE 1984 - Federal Court of Malaya
[CIVIL APPEAL NO. 266 OF 1983]
CONTRACT: Accrual of cause of action - Relevant date - Breach of contract - Whether on failure to deliver on contractual date or on actual completion of contract or on demand and refusal - Relevance of Clause 17 - Provision for liquidated damages - Whether in breach of r. 12(1)(r), Housing Developers (Control and Licensing) Rules - Effect.
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Limitation - Claim for liquidated damages - Whether statute-barred.

Loh Wai Lian v. SEA Housing Corporation Sdn Bhd 03 MARCH 1987 - THE PRIVY COUNCIL
APPEAL NO 39 OF 1985

CONTRACT: Accrual of cause of action - Relevant date - Breach of contract - Whether on failure to deliver on contractual date or on actual completion of contract or on demand and refusal - Relevance of Clause 17 - Provision for liquidated damages - Whether in breach of r. 12(1)(r), Housing Developers (Control and Licensing) Rules - Effect.
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Limitation - Claim for liquidated damages - Whether statute-barred.
CONTRACT: Accrual of cause of action - Relevant date - Breach of contract - Whether on failure to deliver on contractual date or on actual completion of contract or on demand and refusal - Relevance of Clause 17 - Provision for liquidated damages - Whether in breach of r. 12(1)(r), Housing Developers (Control and Licensing) Rules - Effect.
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Limitation - Claim for liquidated damages - Whether statute-barred

NOUVAU MONT DOR (M) SDN. BHD. V. FABER DEVELOPMENT SDN. BHD. 26 MAY 1984 - FEDERAL COURT, JOHOR BAHRU [CIVIL APPEAL NO. 177 OF 1983]
ONG SEOK HENG V. WEE CHEONG MOTOR & HOUSING DEVELOPER SDN. BHD. 12 SEPTEMBER 1990 - HIGH COURT MALAYA, PENANG [ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO. 24-666-1985] Mohamed Dzaiddin J:
Penang Development Corporation V. Teoh Eng Huat & Anor 03 APRIL 1993 - SUPREME COURT, KUALA LUMPUR [CIVIL APPEAL NO. O4-23-1991]

Public Prosecutor v Annamaly a/l Narayanan 25 AUGUST 1988 - HIGH COURT (SEREMBAN)
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO 51-33 OF 1987

Land law - Housing developers - Unlicensed housing development affected by collapse of housing market - Demand by purchasers for refund of purchase moneys - Directive issued by Deputy Minister of Housing directing refunds to be made - Failure of housing developer to comply with directive - Whether directive was ultra vires the Housing Developers (Control and Licensing) Act 1966 - Housing Developers (Control and Licensing) Act 1966, ss 11 & 12

S.E.A. Housing Corp Sdn Bhd v. Lee Poh Choo 19 MARCH 1982 - FEDERAL COURT, KUALA LUMPUR [CIVIL APPEAL NO. 67 OF 1981]
LAND LAW: Housing Developers - Agreement to complete building within 18 months - Delay in completion - Acute shortage of contractors, skilled and construction workers at relevant time - General shortage of building materials - Whether caused by circumstances beyond developer's control to exempt liability - Respondent withholds final instalment payment to set off claim for delay in completion - Demand for balance of the damages - Whether respondent committed breach in holding payment of the final instalment.

Supreme Finance (M) Bhd v. Chandan Daya Sdn Bhd & Anors 14 FEBRUARY 1990 - HIGH COURT MALAYA, KUALA LUMPUR [ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO. F31-3899-1986]

LAND LAW: Charge - Default by chargee - Interest of third party purchaser - Actual notice - Registration - Indefeasibility - Principles on which interest can be varied - Not party to charge documents - Equitable interest - Nature of incumbrance - National Land Code 1965, s. 340 - Civil Law Act 1956, s. 11(a). Whether to be granted

SYKT. MUZWINA DEVELOPMENT SDN. BHD LWN. ABBAS & NGAN 13 OGOS 1990 - MAHKAMAH TINGGI MALAYA, IPOH [SAMAN PEMULA NO. 24-246-90]
SYARIKAT LEAN HUP (LIEW BROTHERS) SDN BHD V. CHEOW CHONG THAI 26 MAY 1988 - HIGH COURT [KUALA LUMPUR] CIVIL APPEAL NO 11-9-1987
TAN YANG LONG & ANOR. V. NEWACRES SDN. BHD. 29 AUGUST 1991 - HIGH COURT MALAYA, SHAH ALAM [ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO. 24-10-89]

Yeo Brothers Co (PTE) Ltd. V. Atlas Properties (PTE) Ltd 23 SEPTEMBER 1987 - HIGH COURT [SINGAPORE] ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO 1178 OF 1985
 

 

Main   Forum  FAQ  Useful Links  Sample Letters  Tribunal  

National House Buyers Association (HBA)

No, 31, Level 3, Jalan Barat, Off Jalan Imbi, 55100, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Tel: 03-21422225 | 012-3345 676 Fax: 03-22601803 Email: info@hba.org.my

2001-2009, National House Buyers Association of Malaysia. All Rights Reserved.