House of another
colour
NST-PROP 10/7/2004
HEARD of an avopaya? It's what happens when biologists successfully
cross an avocado with a papaya. In real estate development, the same
kind of mutation is happening and it only takes a look at the
project launches in our dailies to see them.
What I'm referring to is the current rage of building
apartments suitable for residential accommodation on land zoned for
commercial use, resulting in what is simply known as serviced
apartments.
Agreed, this term is nothing new, having taken
root since the 1980s with projects such as Micasa in Kuala Lumpur's
Tun Razak area. But whereas the Micasa's of Malaysia - and you can
add to it others such as Ascot and PNB Darby Park - are
professionally operated as alternatives to hotels, there's a new
breed that now occupies a grey niche in the industry.
According to the Ministry of Finance's National
Property Information Centre or Napic, as at the end of last year,
there are 60 projects containing 6,215 units "owned and run by
hoteliers or other corporations as - hotel accommodation" and thus,
classified as part of the country's leisure stock. No problems with
these as they don't affect the everyday man seeking a roof over his
head with the least amount of stress.
But in another report covering residential supply,
Napic unveiled for the first time the existence of 12,123 serviced
units that can be sold on a stratified basis and used as homes.
Prior to Napic's 2003 report, such stock had been
included as part of
residential supply due to their nature of use. However, recent
redefinition of terminology has exposed them to be an animal of a
different colour.
Right now, that hue is grey, simply because
although they can be used as homes, the fact they are commercial in
nature means they are not covered by existing housing laws.
As such, their builders need not obtain developer
licences nor advertising and sale permits before taking their
projects to market.
Second, the structure of sale and payment need not
comply with the
Government's Housing and Development Act, and third, buyers cannot
turn to the Housing Tribunal to take up issues such as non-payment
of liquidated ascertained damages in the event of late delivery.
So, even though buyers might be prepared to make
their homes in commercial projects and pay the higher electricity
and water rates applicable in such ventures compared to conventional
housing units, they face an exceptional level of risk.
The apparent oversight in our legislature has
already put quite a few
serviced apartment buyers in a lurch as those who had taken stakes
Rhythm Avenue in Subang, Selangor, Tristar, or CN Galley both in KL
can attest to.
Of course, not all developers are cut from the
wrong piece of cloth. The prime locations of the latter two projects
have allowed them to be resuscitated by apparent white knights,
while many other launches are being undertaken by companies that are
as safe as houses. But as for others ....?
The lingering question has apparently galvanised
the Government into action, and early last month, Housing and Local
Government Minister Datuk Seri Ong Ka Ting said laws will be made to
protect serviced apartment owners. At the same time, he also asked
all State authorities to be careful when approving such projects and
ensure that their developers have the necessary capital and track
record to complete what they promise.
How the regulation takes shape remains to be seen.
Checks with some legislators believed to be involved in drawing it
up said they can't talk as everything's under OSA wraps. That sounds
like a promising start - at least it has gone beyond lip service.
This week, Nicholas examines the forms the new
serviced apartment laws could take - if they could involve re-zoning
of existing projects or amendments to the Housing Act together with
a definition on what serviced apartments are.
The latter looks like the easier, more plausible
and faster route. With
time being of the essence - another 35,000 residential type serviced
apartment are currently in the recently completed, under
construction or planned stages - there is definitely a need to
colour the animal anything but grey. |