Best of first and third worlds
The Sun 16/9/2003
NEXT week, about 450 delegates, comprising academicians, urban managers
and professionals from Asia will gather in Putrajaya to discuss and
pontificate the maintenance of buildings and infrastructure.
The choice of venue could not be better Putrajaya is the
showpiece of Malaysia's capability and capacity to build what is called
"first world infrastructure".
Many delegates will be "shocked and awed" by the majesty
of the buildings, landscaped parks and modern infrastructure.
Malaysia, alas, is also a suitable host because of our
well-known "third world mentality" in building and infrastructure
maintenance.
Although the term is generally attributed to Deputy
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, even the most casual
observer will not fail to see the dirty drains in the town centers, broken
facilities in children's playgrounds and mould walls and fused corridor
lights in high-rise 'buildings.
It is commendable that the Housing and Local Government
Ministry has taken up the challenge of fostering a maintenance culture by
working with the National Institute of Public Administration and the
Eastern Regional Organization for Planning and Housing (Earoph) and invite
experts to discuss and hopefully find some solutions.
Conference is a rather cheap and quick way to identify
underlying causes and search for solutions assuming, of course the right
people are invited to present papers.
But this is the easy and probably even fun part of the
process to promote maintenance of the built environment.
The difficult and more important part of the work is what follows.
Detailed strategies and programmers to promote a maintenance culture have
to be worked through.
Many past conferences have ended as "all talk, but no
action" events, which are clear indications of the third world syndrome.
More importantly there is much work to be done on
strengthening political will and perseverance to implement proposals that
might be painful to friends and supporters.
This is especially so for the proposed national policy
on the maintenance of physical a assets that Housing and Local Government
Minister Datuk Seri Ong Ka Ting seems to have much faith in as a panacea
for poor infrastructure maintenance.
More specifically, realistic procedures are needed to
ensure that those responsible for maintenance do their job properly and if
they fail, will be disciplined.
Fostering and enforcing a maintenance culture on the
service providers is only one side of the coin. The other is to facilitate
and enforce compliance with rules and regulations among the users because
non-compliance usually causes degradation of the environment, including
public infrastructure.
The fact is that many Malaysians just do not comply with
rules and regulations governing buildings and infrastructure use.
For example, despite the laws, campaigns and even
chidings by the prime minister, many Malaysians still discard rubbish
indiscriminately. As a result, even though streets are swept clean in the
morning, by the afternoon, large parts of the towns and cities become
dirty again.
It is possible to run round the clock street cleaning,
but this puts a serious strain on the budget that most local authorities
can ill afford. It is also demoralizing for service providers to see their
efforts wasted on uncaring litterbugs.
To make matters worse, some Malaysians vent their
frustrations by damaging public infrastructure and private property.
Public telephone booths, street signs and park benches become the punching
bags of these anti-socials.
Political leaders must have strong knees to enforce
compliance on both service providers as well as infrastructure users.
Otherwise, Malaysians will continue to build first world
infrastructure but have a third world quality of life. |